|
Battle of Malvern Hill
Other Names: Poindexter’s Farm
Location: Henrico County
Campaign: Peninsula Campaign (March-July 1862)
Date(s): July 1, 1862
Principal Commanders: Maj. Gen. George B. McClellan [US]; Gen. Robert E. Lee [CS]
Forces Engaged: Armies
Estimated Casualties: 8,500 total (US 3,200; CS 5,300)
Result(s): Union victory
| Battle of Malvern Hill |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
Description: The Battle of Malvern Hill was the sixth
and last of the Seven Days Battles. On July 1, 1862, Gen. Robert E. Lee launched a series of disjointed assaults
on the nearly impregnable Union position on Malvern Hill. The Confederates suffered more than 5,300 casualties without gaining
an inch of ground.
Despite his victory, McClellan withdrew to entrench at Harrison’s
Landing on James River, where his army was protected by gunboats. This ended the Peninsula Campaign. When McClellan’s army ceased to threaten Richmond, Lee sent Jackson to
operate against Maj. Gen. John Pope’s army along the Rapidan River, thus initiating the Northern Virginia Campaign.
Although it was the last of the Seven Days Battles and a Union victory, McClellan's career would never recover because, like
previous battlefield successes, he displayed the inability to follow-up or pursue, while Lee's status was elevated because
he had saved the Confederate capitol of Richmond. The public perception of Lee had also changed--he was no longer "Granny
Lee" as he had been previously called--for he had earned the respect and title of "Marse Lee."
"[Malvern Hill] wasn't war; it was murder." Confederate Maj.
Gen. D. H. Hill
| Battle of Malvern Hill Map |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
Battle: Malvern Hill is the story of Confederate infantry
against massed Federal artillery – Southern valor against Union firepower. Late in the afternoon of July 1, 1862, blasts
from Union cannon blanketed this field with smoke. Residents of Staunton, Virginia, more than 100 miles distant, heard the
roar of those guns. Confederate infantry swarmed in front, desperate to
gain a foothold near the Union guns. Their goal: drive the Federals from Malvern Hill and give Robert E. Lee the total victory
he so craved.
| Battle of Malvern Hill Battlefield Map |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
(Battlefield map of Union and Confederate positions, advance, engagement, and repulse at Battle
of Malvern Hill.)
| Richmond National Battlefield Park Map |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
As with most of the battles in the Seven Days, Lee's complex
plan was poorly executed. The approaching soldiers were delayed by severely muddy roads and poor maps. Jackson
arrived at the swampy creek called Western Run and stopped abruptly. Magruder's guides mistakenly sent him on the Long Bridge Road to the southwest, away from the battlefield.
(Right) Map reflects the numerous battles fought around Richmond, including
Malvern Hill, the trenches, forts, Union and Confederate troop movements, and the mileage or distance from Richmond.
Richmond National Battlefield Park, 1958.
Eventually the battle line was assembled with Huger's division
(brigades of Brig. Gens. Ambrose R. Wright and Lewis A. Armistead) on the Confederate right, and D.H. Hill's division (brigades
of Brig. Gen. John Bell Hood and Col. Evander M. Law) on the Quaker Road
to the left. They awaited the Confederate bombardment against Union positions before attacking.
| Battle of Malvern Hill Civil War History |

|
| Map of Union and Confederate Battlefield Positions |
(In both the Union and Confederate front lines, regiments from different brigades, sometimes even from different
divisions and corps, found themselves fighting side by side.)

| Malvern Hill, Virginia |

|
| (Historical Marker) |
Unfortunately for Lee, Henry Hunt struck first, launching one of the
greatest artillery barrages in the war from 1 p.m. to 2:30 p.m. The Union gunners had superior equipment and expertise and
disabled most of the Confederate batteries, which were concentrated on a hill, some 1,200 yards north of the Crew House and
at Poindexter's farm to the northeast.
Despite the setback, Lee sent his infantry forward at 3:30 p.m. and
Armistead's brigade made some progress through the contested lines of Union sharpshooters. By 4 p.m., Magruder arrived and
he was ordered forward to support Armistead. His attack, however, was piecemeal and poorly organized.
Meanwhile, D. H. Hill launched
his division forward along the Quaker Road, past Willis Church. Across the entire line of battle,
the Confederate troops reached only within 200 yards of the Union
Center and were repulsed by nightfall with heavy losses.
| Battle of Malvern Hill and Seven Days Battles Map |

|
| Seven Days Battles of the Peninsula Campaign |
| Malvern Hill Civil War Map |

|
| Battle of Malvern Hill Historic Battlefield Map |
| Battle of Malvern Hill, Virginia, Map |

|
| Civil War Battle of Malvern Hill |
| Magruder and Hill at Malvern Hill |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
The artillery firing at Malvern Hill was so loud that people living 100
miles away claimed to have heard it.
Seven Days Battles and Malvern Hill: The second phase of
the Peninsula Campaign (six major battles and several skirmishes during the Seven Days Battles), which included the Battle
of Malvern Hill, took a negative turn for the Union when Lee assumed command and launched fierce counterattacks just
east of Richmond
in the Seven Days Battles (June 25 – July 1, 1862). Although they are formally considered part of the Peninsula Campaign,
the final battles of June 25 to July 1, with Lee in command and on the offensive against McClellan, are popularly known as
the Seven Days Battles or Seven Days Battles Around Richmond.
| Seven Days Campaign of 1862 Map |

|
| (Civil War Preservation Trust) |
| On the Road to Malvern Hill |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
The Seven Days began on
June 25, 1862, with a Union attack in the minor Battle of Oak Grove, but McClellan quickly lost the initiative as Lee began
a series of attacks at Beaver Dam Creek (Mechanicsville) on June 26, Gaines' Mill on June 27, the minor actions at Garnett's
and Golding's Farm on June 27 and June 28, and the attack on the Union rear guard at Savage's Station on June 29. McClellan's
Army of the Potomac continued its retreat toward the safety of Harrison's Landing on the James River. Lee's final opportunity to intercept
the Union Army was at the Battle of Glendale on June 30, but poorly executed orders allowed his enemy to escape to a strong
defensive position on Malvern Hill. At the Battle of Malvern Hill on July 1, Lee launched futile frontal assaults and suffered
heavy casualties in the face of strong infantry and artillery defenses.
The Seven Days ended with McClellan's
army in relative safety next to the James River, having suffered almost 16,000 casualties
during the retreat. Lee's army, which had been on the offensive during the Seven Days, lost over 20,000. As Lee became convinced
that McClellan would not resume his threat against Richmond,
he moved north for the Northern Virginia Campaign and the Maryland Campaign.
| Battle of Malvern Hill Map |

|
| Malvern Hill Battlefield Map |
(Map of the Battle of Malvern Hill showing Union and Confederate
Battlefield Positions on July 1, 1862.)
| Stonewall Jackson Advances |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
Malvern Aftermath: ”More than five
thousand dead and wounded men were on the ground,” a Union officer reported next dawn, ”but enough were alive
and moving to give the field a singular crawling effect.”
Gen. Lee's army had suffered a staggering 5,355 casualties (versus 3,214
Union) in this failed and tragic effort, but Lee continued to follow the Union army all the way to Harrison's Landing. Malvern
Hill also ended the Peninsula Campaign. When McClellan's army ceased to threaten Richmond, Lee sent Jackson to operate against
Maj. Gen. John Pope's army along the Rapidan River, thus initiating the Northern Virginia Campaign.
| Watercolor of the Battle of Malvern Hill |

|
| (Sneden) |
| Willis Church & Malvern Hill |

|
| (Click to Enlarge) |
Peninsula Campaign Analysis: Both sides
claimed victory, when McClellan and Johnston initially opposed each other during the Peninsula Campaign, but neither side's
accomplishment was impressive. George B. McClellan's advance on Richmond was halted and the Army of Northern Virginia fell back into the Richmond defensive works. Despite claiming victory, McClellan was shaken by the experience.
He wrote to his wife, "I am tired of the sickening sight of the battlefield, with its mangled corpses & poor suffering
wounded! Victory has no charms for me when purchased at such cost." He redeployed all of his army except for the V Corps south
of the river, and although he continued to plan for a siege and the capture of Richmond,
he lost the strategic initiative. An offensive begun by the new Confederate commander, Gen. Robert E. Lee, would be planned
while the Union troops passively sat in the outskirts of Richmond.
| Malvern Hill Photograph |

|
| Picture of Malvern Hill |
(Photograph in 2005
of the Malvern Hills situated in the English Midlands, UK. The Celtic name Moel-bryn means
Bare-Hill, and a later spelling was Maelfern, aka Malvern.)
The
Seven Days Battles drove the Union Army back to the James River and saved the Confederate
capital. The change in leadership of the Confederate Army in the field, from Joe Johnston to Robert E. Lee, as a result of
Seven Pines had a profound effect on the war. On June 24, 1862, McClellan's massive Army of the Potomac was within 6 miles
of the Confederate capital of Richmond; Union soldiers wrote
that they could hear church bells ringing in the city. Within 90 days, however, McClellan had been driven from the Peninsula,
Pope had been soundly beaten at the Second Battle of Bull Run, and battle lines were 20 miles from the Union capital in Washington. It would take almost two more years before the Union Army
again got that close to Richmond, and almost three years before
it captured it.
| Civil War Battle of Malvern Hill, Virginia |

|
| (Historical Marker) |
(Battle of Malvern Hill Historical Marker: Against the Federals holding
this eminence, the Confederates delivered repeated assaults from the North on July 1, 1862, and lost about 5,000 men in the
final, indecisive Battle of the Seven Days Campaign. That night McClellan withdrew to Harrison's Landing, near Westover.)
McClellan, Peninsula Campaign, Civil War, and Lincoln: McClellan's Peninsula Campaign in 1862 ended in failure, with retreats from attacks
by General Robert E. Lee's smaller army and an unfulfilled plan to seize the Confederate capital of Richmond. His performance at the bloody Battle of Antietam blunted Lee's invasion of Maryland, but allowed Lee to eke out a precarious tactical draw and
avoid destruction, despite being outnumbered. As a result, McClellan's leadership skills during battles were questioned by
President Abraham Lincoln, who eventually removed him from command, first as general-in-chief, then from the Army of the Potomac. Lincoln was famously quoted
as saying, "If General McClellan does not want to use the army, I would like to borrow it for a time!"
| President Lincoln and McClellan in 1862 |

|
| (Library of Congress) |
General McClellan also failed to maintain the trust of Lincoln, and proved to be frustratingly derisive of, and
insubordinate to, his commander-in-chief. After he was relieved of command, McClellan became the unsuccessful Democratic nominee
opposing Lincoln in the 1864 presidential election.
Lee, Seven Days Battles, and Civil War: At the outbreak of war, Robert E. Lee was appointed
to command all of Virginia's forces, but upon the formation of the Confederate States Army, he was named one
of its first five full generals. Lee did not wear the insignia of a Confederate general, but only the three stars of a Confederate
colonel, equivalent to his last U.S. Army rank. He did not intend to wear a general's insignia until the Civil War had been
won and he could be promoted, in peacetime, to general in the Confederate Army.
Lee's
first field assignment was commanding Confederate forces in western Virginia,
where he was defeated at the Battle of Cheat Mountain and was widely blamed for Confederate setbacks. He was then sent to organize the coastal defenses along the Carolina and
Georgia seaboard, where he was hampered
by the lack of an effective Confederate navy. Once again blamed by the press, he became military adviser to Confederate President
Jefferson Davis, former U.S. Secretary of War. While in Richmond,
Lee was ridiculed as the 'King of Spades' for his excessive digging of trenches around the capitol. These trenches, however,
would play an important role in battles near the end of the war.
| General Robert E. Lee in 1863 |

|
| (Library of Congress) |
In
the spring of 1862, during the Peninsula Campaign, the Union Army of the Potomac under George McClellan advanced upon Richmond from Fort Monroe,
eventually reaching the eastern edges of the Confederate capital along the Chickahominy
River. Following the wounding of Gen. Joseph E. Johnston at the Battle
of Seven Pines, on June 1, 1862, Lee assumed command of the Army of Northern Virginia, his first opportunity to lead an army
in the field. Newspaper editorials of the day objected to his appointment due to concerns that Lee would not be aggressive
and would wait for the Union army to come to him. Early in the war his men referred to him as "Granny Lee" because of his
allegedly timid style of command. After the Seven Days Battles and until the end of the war, however, his men respectively
referred to him as "Marse Robert." He oversaw substantial strengthening of Richmond's
defenses during the first three weeks of June and then launched a series of attacks, the Seven Days Battles, against McClellan's
forces. Lee's attacks resulted in heavy Confederate casualties and they were marred by clumsy tactical performances by his
subordinates, but his aggressive actions thwarted McClellan, who retreated to a point on the James River
where Union naval forces were in control. These successes led to a rapid turn-around of public opinion and the newspaper editorials
quickly changed their tune on Lee's aggressiveness. Following his defeat at Gettysburg, Lee
sent a letter of resignation to Pres. Davis on August 8, 1863, but Davis
refused Lee's request. On January 31, 1865, Lee was promoted to general-in-chief of Confederate forces.
Richmond in History and Memory: The Civil War (1861-1865)
remains the central, most defining event in American history. Richmond, Virginia, was
at the heart of the conflict. As the industrial and political capital of the Confederacy, Richmond
was the physical and psychological prize over which two mighty American armies contended in bloody battle from 1861 to 1865.
At stake were some of the founding principles of the United States
as the growing nation divided over the existence and expansion of slavery. Only after the new Confederacy fired on a federal
fort in Charleston harbor and Lincoln had called for troops
to preserve the Union, did Virginia join the Confederacy.
As war began, neither side anticipated the brutal clashes and home front destruction that brought death or injury to more
than one million Americans and devastation to a broad landscape, much of it in Virginia.
| Richmond, Virginia, in 1865 |

|
| (Richmond National Battlefield Park) |
(Photograph) Waterfront view
of Richmond’s capitol building after the evacuation and fire in 1865.
Cannon boomed within earshot
of Richmond.
All of its residents saw their lives transformed. Wartime Richmond,
swollen by government, the military, refugees, prisoners, and the wounded, lived with anxiety and hope. Martial law and rationing
were routine. Disease claimed thousands.
Landowners outside Richmond saw their farms converted into battlefields. Previously unknown
place-names like Cold Harbor, Gaines’ Mill, Malvern Hill, and New Market Heights attained national significance for the key
battles that were fought in the vicinity of Richmond. Naval
military history was made at the Battle of Drewry's Bluff. Robert E. Lee fought his first battle as commander of the Army of Northern Virginia at Beaver Dam Creek in 1862; Ulysses
S. Grant’s army experienced unprecedented futility on the bloody fields of Cold Harbor.
Titans tangled repeatedly here. Earthworks scarred miles of farmland. Wheat fields became killing fields. Cemeteries started
dotting the landscape.
On April 4 and 5, 1865,
President Lincoln made a remarkable visit to Richmond as he
pressed to conclude the war that had cost more than 620,000 lives “with malice toward none, with charity for all…”
His assassination, just days later, portended a less charitable course for the aftermath.
Today, the Richmond
National Battlefield Park
preserves more than 1900 acres of Civil War resources in 13 units, including the main visitor center at the famous Tredegar
Iron Works and the Chimborazo Medical Museum, on the site of Chimborazo
Hospital.
(Sources listed at bottom of page.)
Recommended
Reading: To The Gates of Richmond: The Peninsula Campaign, by Stephen W. Sears. From Kirkus Reviews: In George B. McClellan
(1988) and his work editing the papers of the Union general, Sears established himself as the critical but indispensable authority
on flawed ``Little Mac.'' Now, in a stirring prequel to Landscape Turned Red (1983), his superb account of the Battle of Antietam,
the author reaffirms his mastery of historical narrative. In March 1862, the egotistical but timorous McClellan was prodded
by Lincoln into finally launching the first major offensive by the Army of the Potomac.
Instead of marching directly overland from Washington, McClellan used Federal sea power to
advance on Richmond by way of the peninsula between the York
and James Rivers. Continued below…
The "Grand
Campaign,'' however, soon belied its creator's Napoleonic pretensions by becoming a three-and-a-half-month nightmare of feints
and pitched battles, ultimately engaging up to a combined quarter-million men on both sides and leaving one of every four
men dead, wounded, or missing. Using hundreds of eyewitness accounts, Sears demonstrates how the most creative use of military
technology (ironclad warships, 200-pounder rifled cannon, battlefield telegraph, and aerial reconnaissance) existed side by
side with the most appalling mismanagement (Stonewall Jackson's uncharacteristic lethargy; McClellan's mistaken belief that
the numerically inferior rebels possessed a two-to-one manpower advantage; out-of-sync attacks by both Confederate and Union
generals). Above all, though, Sears casts the campaign as a clash of wits and wills between McClellan--whom he accuses of
losing ``the courage to command''--and Robert E. Lee--who, upon succeeding the wounded Joseph E. Johnson as head of the Army
of Northern Virginia, seized the initiative, repulsed the assault in the series of ``Seven Days'' battles, and began his long
journey into legend. An authoritative, ironic, and stirring addition to Civil War annals. “…[No] serious study
of the Peninsula Campaign is possible without this book.” Americancivilwarhistory.org
(Sources listed at bottom of page.)
Recommended
Reading: Extraordinary Circumstances: The Seven Days Battles (Library Binding). Description: EXTRAORDINARY CIRCUMSTANCES tells the story of the Seven Days Battles,
the first campaign in the Civil War in which Robert E. Lee led the Army of Northern Virginia. One of the most decisive military
campaigns in Western history, the Seven Days were fought in the area southeast of the Confederate capitol of Richmond from
June 25 to July 1, 1862--and began a string of events leading to the Emancipation Proclamation and the shift toward total
war.
Recommended
Reading: The Richmond Campaign of 1862: The Peninsula and the
Seven Days (Military Campaigns of the
Civil War). Description: The Richmond campaign of April-July
1862 ranks as one of the most important military operations of the first years of the American Civil War. Key political, diplomatic,
social, and military issues were at stake as Robert E. Lee and George B. McClellan faced off on the peninsula between the
York and James Rivers. The climactic clash came on June 26-July 1 in what became known as the Seven Days battles, when Lee,
newly appointed as commander of the Confederate forces, aggressively attacked the Union army. Casualties for the entire campaign
exceeded 50,000, more than 35,000 of whom fell during the Seven Days. Continued below…
This
book offers nine essays in which well-known Civil War historians explore questions regarding high command, strategy and tactics,
the effects of the fighting upon politics and society both North and South, and the ways in which emancipation figured in
the campaign. The authors have consulted previously untapped manuscript sources and reinterpreted more familiar evidence,
sometimes focusing closely on the fighting around Richmond and sometimes looking more broadly at the background
and consequences of the campaign.
Recommended
Reading: Seven Days Before Richmond: McClellan's Peninsula Campaign
of 1862 and its Aftermath (Hardcover).
Description: Combining meticulous research with a unique perspective, Seven Days Before Richmond examines the 1862 Peninsula
Campaign of Union General George McClellan and the profound effects it had on the lives of McClellan and Confederate General
Robert E. Lee, as well as its lasting impact on the war itself. Continued below…
Rudolph Schroeder's
twenty-five year military career and combat experience bring added depth to his analysis of the Peninsula Campaign, offering
new insight and revelation to the subject of Civil War battle history. Schroeder analyzes this crucial campaign from its genesis
to its lasting consequences on both sides. Featuring a detailed bibliography and a glossary of terms, this work contains the
most complete Order of Battle of the Peninsula Campaign ever compiled, and it also includes the identification of commanders
down to the regiment level. In addition, this groundbreaking volume includes several highly-detailed maps that trace the Peninsula
Campaign and recreate this pivotal moment in the Civil War. Impeccably detailed and masterfully told, Seven Days Before Richmond
is an essential addition to Civil War scholarship. Schroeder artfully enables us to glimpse the innermost thoughts and motivations
of the combatants and makes history truly come alive.
Recommended
Reading: The Peninsula Campaign of 1862: A Military Analysis (Hardcover). Description: The largest offensive of the Civil War, involving army,
navy, and marine forces, the Peninsula Campaign has inspired many history books. No previous work, however, analyzes Union
general George B. McClellan's massive assault toward Richmond
in the context of current and enduring military doctrine. The Peninsula Campaign of 1862: A Military Analysis fills this void.
Background history is provided for continuity, but the heart of this book is military analysis and the astonishing extent
to which the personality traits of generals often overwhelm even the best efforts of their armies. Continued below…
The Peninsula
Campaign lends itself to such a study. Lessons for those studying the art of war are many. On water, the first ironclads forever
changed naval warfare. At the strategic level, McClellan's inability to grasp Lincoln's grand objective becomes evident. At the operational
level, Robert E. Lee's difficulty in synchronizing his attacks deepens the mystique of how he achieved so much with so little.
At the tactical level, the Confederate use of terrain to trade space for time allows for a classic study in tactics. Moreover,
the campaign is full of lessons about the personal dimension of war. McClellan's overcaution, Lee's audacity, and Jackson's personal exhaustion all provide valuable insights for today's
commanders and for Civil War enthusiasts still debating this tremendous struggle. Historic photos and detailed battle maps
make this study an invaluable resource for those touring the many battlegrounds from Young's Mill and Yorktown through Fair Oaks to the final throes of the Seven Days' Battles. Kevin Dougherty, Hattiesburg,
Mississippi, is professor of military science at the University of Southern Mississippi. He is the
author of The Coastal War in North and South Carolina. J.
Michael Moore, Yorktown, Virginia, is the registrar of Lee Hall Mansion.
Sources: National Park Service; Richmond National Battlefield Park; Official
Records of the Union and Confederate Armies; Civil War Preservation Trust (CWPT); Burton, Brian K., Extraordinary Circumstances: The Seven Days Battles, Indiana University Press; Eicher, David J.,
The Longest Night: A Military History of the Civil War, Simon & Schuster, 2001; Esposito, Vincent J., West Point Atlas
of American Wars, Frederick A. Praeger, 1959; Kennedy, Frances H., ed., The Civil War Battlefield Guide, 2nd ed., Houghton
Mifflin Co., 1998; Library of Congress; National Archives.
|